Review of <i>The Cambridge History of Science. Volume 1, Ancient Science</i>, ed. Alexander Jones and Liba Taub. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018. - HAL-SHS - Sciences de l'Homme et de la Société
Autre Publication Scientifique Journal of the American Oriental Society Année : 2021

Review of The Cambridge History of Science. Volume 1, Ancient Science, ed. Alexander Jones and Liba Taub. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018.

Résumé

As one would expect from a Cambridge History volume dedicated to "ancient science," this book provides a coherent and accessible overview of the history, sources, philosophy, and sociology of the principal fields of natural inquiry in the ancient world. In terms of geographical span, the book covers Mesopotamia (4 chapters, 93 pages), Egypt (4 chapters, 62 pages), the Mediterranean (16 chapters, 321 pages), India (3 chapters, 66 pages), and China (3 chapters, 65 pages). In terms of subject matter, to each civilization/language-tradition are devoted independent chapters on medicine, mathematics, and astronomy/astrology, though not necessarily in that order, and, to the Greco-Roman world, additional chapters on zoology, botany, geography, optics, harmonics, mechanics, and alchemy. Lastly, in the case of Mesopotamia, Egypt, and the Mediterranean, this ideaoriented core is complimented by introductory chapters outlining the social, historical, and philosophical background relevant to the chapters that follow. As to framing, as presented in the Introduction, the editors' approach might be described as a mix of thoughtful minimalism and nonintervention. The Introduction is barely four pages long, and it is largely dedicated to highlighting the pitfalls that the volume aims to avoid: essentialism, anachronism, "scientific" and Greco-Roman exceptionalism, insisting on overly rigid definitions, and reading technical literature independent of context. "Science," for example, is given a loose working definition comprising "three elements that did not all have to be present in a particular tradition: the collection and organization of information and knowledge; prediction; and causal explanation" (p. 2). The editors leave it at that, they deny any pretentions at exhaustiveness or perfect historiographical objectivity, and they inform us that the authors were essentially free to organize their chapters and interpret "ancient" and "science" as they saw fit. Where the editors do speak out, if only briefly, is in their interest in exploring: [1] transmission and interconnection, both across and within individual language cultures, notably between different fields and across the divide between specialist and amateur; [2] "the people who engaged in scientific work, their education, their motivations, and their professional status" (p. 2); [3] emic/actor's concepts, values, and categorization; and [4] cultural, institutional, and religious settings. Barring the possibility that Alexander Jones and Liba Taub are in fact Daoist sages, of course, it is unlikely that this five-part, thirty-chapter tome spontaneously organized itself into something so coherent without quite a bit of active direction and intervention on their part. In other words, their vision for this volume, if not the field, is to be found realized through their editorial work on the 614 pages of the body rather than pontificated upon in the Introduction. Throughout, there is a relative unity to each chapter's minimalism in aim and theoretical/ideological apparatus, as adumbrated in the Introduction, and, where appropriate, the authors naturally engage with the four topics of interest enumerated above (those of
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
Morgan - 2021 - Review Cambridge History of Science vol 1.pdf (90.14 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origine Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)

Dates et versions

halshs-03445350 , version 1 (23-11-2021)

Identifiants

Citer

Daniel Patrick Morgan. Review of The Cambridge History of Science. Volume 1, Ancient Science, ed. Alexander Jones and Liba Taub. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018.. 2021, pp.452-454. ⟨10.7817/jameroriesoci.141.2.0452⟩. ⟨halshs-03445350⟩
62 Consultations
113 Téléchargements

Altmetric

Partager

More