Where is the Law Living? - Archive ouverte HAL Access content directly
Journal Articles Droit et Société Year : 2018

Where is the Law Living?

(1) , (2) ,
Emilia Schijman
Noé Wagener
  • Function : Author
  • PersonId : 935997
  • IdRef : 165614013
Daniela Piana
  • Function : Author


This article highlights the shortcomings of S. Silbey’s conception of law in enabling her to fully address the compelling question of the “social sources” of law. However, can we disregard the problem of identifying when, precisely, the practices we observe are not so much the expression of the domination of the State mediated by the rules it forges than a form of “living law” in action at the level of a social group? Independently of the criteria of law, when do we switch to one side or the other? Maybe it is the research methodology itself – the absence of an ethnographic approach – that prevents S. Silbey from describing fully the reciprocity of the interrelationships between social practices and formal law, and thus going beyond the mere question of the daily experience of the latter.
Not file

Dates and versions

halshs-02365036 , version 1 (15-11-2019)


  • HAL Id : halshs-02365036 , version 1


Emilia Schijman, Noé Wagener, Daniela Piana. Where is the Law Living?: Juridicity and Methods of Research in the Works of Susan Silbey. Droit et Société, 2018, After Legal Consciousness Studies : dialogues transatlantiques et transdisciplinaires, 3 (100). ⟨halshs-02365036⟩
49 View
0 Download


Gmail Facebook Twitter LinkedIn More